Autonoomsed piirkonnad täisdemokraatliku ja hübriidrežiimi tingimustes: Hispaania Kuningriigis asuva Kataloonia ja Venemaa Föderatsioonis asuva Tatarstani näitel
Date
2012
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Tartu Ülikool
Abstract
In the 21st century, the definite quantity of autonomous regions is contested due
to political ambiguity, but the general estimation is that there are under fifty.
Autonomous regions with a limited range of legislative and executive power can be
defined by several parameters. Primarily historical development, geographical position,
ethnic homogeneity, subsidiarity principle and the future outlook of independence.
Regarding autonomous regions, there are ones located, both in democratic countries
(e.g. United Kingdom, Denmark, Finland), and in non-democratic countries (e.g. Iraq,
China).
The aim on this undergraduate thesis, is to analyse and to compare autonomous
regions, located inside the territory of democratic vis-a-vis non-democratic countries.
The thesis, will compare two variables; The Republic of Tatarstan, the federal subject of
the Russian Federation and the autonomous entity of Catalan in the Kingdom of Spain.
The research, will analyse the differences of regional autonomy, regarding its
geographical and political position, either in a democratic or a non-democratic region.
Secondly, it will analyse the interests of the central Governments, regarding their
strategy on the enlargement or further restrictions, for the autonomous entity. Thirdly, it
will study how the autonomous regions have used the power given to them, and what
are there perspectives for the future. The thesis paper, will use both qualitative and
quantitative research methods to analyse and compare the independent variables which
affect the two autonomous regions.
The hypothesis is – The preconditions and “true” reasons for an autonomous
region to rise from the cradle are quite similar, but regarding further development of the
regions, then the autonomous entities in democracies are more likely to gain more
power and stability, than the ones in non-democracies.
In the research, in order to compare the two autonomous regions, there is a need
to analyse the following independent variables: the historical process of regional
development, geographical position, population variance, economical power, foreign
policy goals, stability of the central power, and the extent of sovereignty given.
The research is divided into two parts. The first part will analyse the theoretical
definition of an autonomous region. In the second part, the two autonomous regions will
be compared, regarding their historical development, their current political and
economical situation as well as their future perspectives. Finally, the paper will make
assumptions, regarding the possibility of these autonomous regions of becoming
independent countries as well as the scope of threats which could occur in the case of
devolution.